JINYU · Buyer question
How should I compare two replacement cabinet proposals against the same survey?
Give each proposal its own column in a comparison sheet. Put the selected survey date and revision at the top. In each column, record the exact model code, offered configuration and selected cabinet drawing reference, revision and date. Separate cabinet body dimensions from packaging, installation space and door or service-panel opening envelopes. Link each copied dimension to its source drawing and revision. A photograph or catalogue size may omit details needed for the comparison.
Use one fixed height datum and the same wall reference for both proposals. State whether the cabinet front or rear follows the selected alignment line. For each proposed footprint, link the front-left, front-right, rear-left and rear-right floor readings to their measured positions and dates. Include the customer side and sign convention. If an option moves the footprint, retain the original readings and add measurements at the revised corners. Record concealed or inaccessible points as unmeasured.
Keep measured floor levels and retained joinery underside levels in rows separate from proposed cabinet body-bottom levels and support settings. For each offered configuration, compare the base drawing and support locations with that configuration's own footprint survey. A higher proposed base level changes the cabinet position in the elevation, not the recorded floor level. Use the joinery sections at that footprint to compare worktop intersections and access around the cabinet.
Add rows for service positions, staff access, moving parts and the equipment route. Label each entry as a site measurement, an offered drawing dimension, proposed site work or an unanswered question. Record each assumption separately, with its source document or person, date and the proposal and survey point it applies to. For example, an assumed clearance after a fitting is removed remains separate from the measured opening with that fitting in place. Keep installation allowances and component details with the proposal whose documents state them. Where the proposals use different survey revisions, list the changed measurements and reference the selected survey revision in both columns. Identify entries still based on earlier measurements or offered drawings.
When later measurements replace an assumption, link the replacement readings to that assumption in the revised sheet. Give the measurement date, marked location and surfaces measured. If a footprint or measurement point changes, show the new location relative to the same datum and wall reference. Keep the earlier readings and assumptions with their original survey and drawing references. A reading at the old footprint does not establish the clearance at the revised one.
Send the sheet and marked survey views through the inquiry entry with both configuration references. Date each revised comparison sheet and list the changed measurements, assumptions and offered drawings. For each proposal, identify the selected survey revision and the selected offered drawing reference and revision. Keep earlier comparison sheets with the documents used for each review. The reviewer can then trace each difference to a measured site condition, a proposed change or a specific offered drawing.
Prepare this information
- Selected survey date and revision, fixed height datum and named alignment for both proposals
- Exact offered configurations and selected cabinet drawing references, revisions and dates in separate columns
- Measured site levels separated from proposed base levels, support settings and site work
- Assumptions linked to their source document or person, date, proposal and survey point
- Replacement readings linked to the assumption, measurement date, location and measured surfaces, with earlier comparisons retained
Compare the open-front display series